I once loved a girl who was weird and unfashionable, in a time a couple years before that in itself became fashionable.
We had met when a friend of mine dumped a girl named Shelly (pseudonym) — rather rudely, and coldly — and then, after asking her if they could still be friends, was surprised to have her try and hook him up with a friend of hers from across town. This is in Southern California, and it was the first year of high school, in ‘89 or so, and we didn’t have cars, none of us. So across town might as well have meant in Michigan, for all we were likely to actually meet this girl.
But my friend fell deeply in love with this new girl, who he knew only from phone calls and a picture she sent in one of their frequent letters. And this girl lived not with her parents, but with a friend and her parents — whom I shall call K. My friend’s new penpal couldn’t go on a date without arranging for a date with her friend, whose parents were nice enough to put her up. And my friend couldn’t go on a date until he got a ride across town. The solution to both issues was me — both as a hookup for the friend and as somebody whose parent would give us a ride.
And so it was that K and began talking, and she was unapologetic about who she was. She liked Star Trek, and at an age where I had mercilessly closeted myself about my geekiness in a quest for sex, it was frightening and cool to be able to talk about Star Trek with a girl. She also said she had a lazy eye (which made the upcoming blind date a pretty miserable prospect for me,) and had never had a serious boyfriend, and from her description of herself, she was painfully uncool.
But I had my boy’s back, and we went on the blind date, and it turned out his date had lied about just about everything — she’d sent a photo of her cousin, she was massively overweight, had bad hair, bad skin, and was a much better conversationalist on the phone than in person (which is the lesson for here, and an obvious one at that — never trust an ex-girlfriend you hurt badly to set you up with your rebound girl.) Whereas my girl was still a bit uncool and into Trek — but didn’t have a lazy eye, a story she made up just to freak me out.
That doesn’t sound like a big deal, but her attitude was so alien to anybody I knew in high school - she didn’t give a shit. When everybody else was putting their best foot forward, she acted like hers was a wooden leg. When everybody else would have lied about their idiosyncracies, she came forward honestly — I’m a geek. I like Trek. I play accordion. I love my family. Take it or leave it.
There is a kind of insane power about that. Self-knowledge and self-assuredness is worth its weight in gold in high school, and even if she was uncool, there was a kind of iron in her. And me, sexually submissive, so ashamed of being a geek that I was as closeted as the gay kids in school, she was this white hot candle, to which I simultaneously was drawn and repulsed.
It took us two years to have a second date, because of the distances involved, and also — to be frank — because I found the idea of wanting her so scary. Could I take her out without admitting my own geekiness? Could I give up on the front I was living and just say, “Yeah, she doesn’t dress like a surfer, she doesn’t spend hours on her hair, but she’s cute and smart and awesome?”
When we did meet again, she came over to my place. And we made small talk and we chatted about this and that, and after a while she looked me dead in the eye and said, “So, am I going to get a hug?”
And within instants, we were up against each other in the kind of feverish and rough foreplay you only see in movies. It was, until I met my wife, the hottest moment I ever had with a girl. Foreplay with this girl was better than sex with all of the repressed little surfers I was dating, and better than most hookups I had in college.
And I remember, there was one moment, where I dropped to my knees, and started to go down on her. And she grabbed me by the face and said, “Get up.” And there was no high school girl doubt in her voice. No, “I’m not ready” quavering. And I started to explain to her that she’d like it — because even at 16 I was ferociously good at oral sex, because it allowed me to scratch that submissive itch, and because my first girlfriend had trained me for weeks back when I was 12. But she looked me dead in the eye and simply said, “I don’t find it pleasurable.”
It was like being kicked in the head. Here was a girl — no, a woman — who knew what she wanted, and wouldn’t let you wheedle anything out of her. It was her game. And her attention was on me, the entire time, letting me go where she wanted, steering me away from places she didn’t. She was in control, at the age of 16, like no woman I’d ever met or ever would meet for a good decade.
She was dominant. I mean, I knew it at the time but couldn’t put words to it. She was comfortable in her own skin and strong and powerful, and I had never imagined a girl at that age could be like that.
So of course, after that session I was deeply in love with her, but wouldn’t allow myself to see her again. Because she made me feel submissive, and it wasn’t something I was ready to be, even though sex dreams — when I had them — were all submissive fantasies, about being overpowered and controlled and forced to do things. About being a slave. And because I was a nasty little dork full of self-loathing and repression and it wasn’t the right time to be out and kinky or geeky.
And we talked via phone all the time, and this girl admitted she loved me. She loved me so much, wanted me so nakedly and unashamedly about her feelings, and I could never bring myself to commit. Why not? I don’t know. I was a big stupid dumbass. When I moved across country after I graduated, we talked all the time via phone, and I admitted I loved her, too, but I could never make that leap to getting back to her. I started wandering across country in my car, working odd jobs as I made my way back to So Cal, and in the back of my head I knew our old home town would be my end point, but she was in charge of her life and I guess she got tired of waiting, and joined the Navy while I was in Washington State. We kept up talking for a few more weeks, and then our talks got more infrequent. The last I heard, a year later, when we managed to catch each other on the phone — she was hinting that she’d discovered full-on kink — as a top or a bottom, I was never clear, but she openly admitted to hanging out with a kinky friend and in his room, finally holding a whip and getting dreamy-eyed. Once again, she was nakedly unashamed about being aroused, about what she wanted, what she was learning she liked.
And there I was, painfully aroused, and painfully closeted. Unable to say, “Holy shit, you are everything I’ve been looking for.”
And so she will always remain my archetypal dominant woman. Even at 16, 17, 18, she was so clear-eyed, so strong, so unapologetic. She knew what she wanted, out of life and herself and her man. And I just didn’t have the balls to reach out and give it to her. And that to me is what dominance is about — that sureness. That frank gaze that doesn’t flinch. That personality that is content with itself, warts and all. And that sexual knowledge of her own wants and needs. She’s the model for what I wanted in a dominant woman, and when I see women who have that look to them, I melt.
And it took me 18 years to find another. It was worth the wait, but I still wonder what happened to my first, the one that got away.